The documentary films made by Frank Schaeffer and his father, Francis Schaeffer, unintentionally sparked a violent culture war around the issue of abortion, leading to acts of violence and polarization within the evangelical community.
The influence of Francis Schaeffer's documentaries on activists and the intense opposition to abortion they generated contributed to the intertwining of the culture war over abortion with political movements, impacting electoral politics and judicial appointments.
Deep dives
The Surprising Origin of a Violent Culture War
This podcast episode explores the unexpected beginnings of one of America's most violent culture wars, which still continues today. It delves into the story of a young boy named Frank Schaffer growing up in a Swiss mountain commune run by his father, Francis Schaffer, a Christian philosopher. Frank's father made a Christian art history documentary, and Frank, aspiring to be a Hollywood director, saw it as an opportunity to showcase his filmmaking skills. However, midway through production, Frank decided to incorporate scenes about abortion, a topic that was not typically associated with evangelical Christians at the time. The documentaries, filled with vivid imagery and controversial messages, were initially a success, but soon sparked intense protests and increased polarization, ultimately leading to the murder of an abortion provider. Frank and his father, plagued by remorse, attempted to undo the damage they believed their films had caused, but their efforts to change evangelical minds proved challenging.
The Escalation of the Culture War
As the consequences of the abortion documentaries intensified, the evangelical community became deeply divided. Protests and counter-protests surrounded their film screenings, drawing media attention and further fueling the polarization. Feminist groups also began to take notice, opposing the anti-abortion message. This clash of ideologies marked the beginning of the culture war, with the issue of abortion emerging as a potent wedge. The podcast highlights that the influence of Francis Schaffer's documentaries on activists like Jim Copp ignited passionate opposition to abortion, leading to acts of violence, such as bombings and shootings targeting abortion clinics and providers. The episode also emphasizes how the culture war over abortion became intertwined with political movements, influencing electoral politics and judicial appointments.
Unintended Consequences and Personal Reflection
The podcast discusses the unintended consequences of Francis Schaffer's films, which intensified the battle over abortion and polarized the evangelical community. While Francis eventually distanced himself from the movement, expressing disdain for the unsavory alliances formed in the name of evangelical activism, he and his son, Frank, remained haunted by the repercussions of their work. Frank, in particular, expressed profound remorse for the violence perpetrated in the name of their films and dedicated himself to advocating for women's rights and undoing the damage caused. However, the podcast acknowledges the ongoing impact of the culture war, highlighting the recent controversial abortion legislation in Texas as evidence that the ripples set in motion by the Schaffers' documentaries continue to shape the conversation around reproductive rights in America.
It's the early 1970s. Frank Schaeffer is an American kid living in the Swiss Alps – the son of an influential Christian art historian - who daydreams of one day making Hollywood films. But for that he needs a show-reel to prove himself. The ripples of Frank's creative ambitions will help trigger one of America's most violent culture wars around the legalization of abortion and Roe vs Wade.
Written and presented by Jon Ronson
Produced by Sarah Shebbeare
Original music by Phil Channell
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode