Coltan Scrivner, expert in psychology of horror and true crime, talks about why people are drawn to horror, true crime and scary genres; and whether terrifying entertainment can be good for mental health. He also discusses the paradox of enjoying horror movies, the impact of technology on health, and the connection between morbid curiosity and horror. Additionally, he explores the interpretation of scores on the morbid curiosity scale, busts the stereotype that horror fans lack empathy, and highlights personality traits associated with horror movie enjoyment.
Read more
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
Many horror fans are genuinely scared while watching scary content and find it to be a learning experience that helps them develop as individuals.
Enjoying horror movies and possessing morbid curiosity does not indicate a lack of empathy or pathological traits, and horror fans tend to have greater compassion compared to non-horror fans.
Deep dives
Exploring Morbid Curiosity and Scary Play
Dr. Colton Scrivener, a behavioral scientist, discusses his research on morbid curiosity and scary play. He defines morbid curiosity as a curiosity or interest in potentially dangerous things, whether fictionally or in real life. Contrary to the belief that only certain individuals possess morbid curiosity, research shows that it is actually a trait that is normally distributed among people. In terms of horror movies, popular assumption suggests that people enjoy them for the adrenaline rush, but Dr. Scrivener's studies show that only a small number of horror fans are actually adrenaline junkies. Instead, many are genuinely scared and feel that engaging in scary play helps them learn about themselves and their limits of fear, building self-confidence and helping them overcome real-life challenges. While fear can be healthy to a certain extent, knowing when it becomes too much is important. People regulate their arousal and engagement with scary material to maintain a balance of enjoyment and fear. Contrary to the stereotype, enjoying horror movies and possessing morbid curiosity does not indicate a lack of empathy or pathological traits. In fact, Dr. Scrivener's studies suggest that horror fans tend to have greater compassion and do not display any significant differences in empathy compared to non-horror fans. Morbid curiosity is associated with higher openness and rebelliousness, but not strongly correlated with the Big Five personality traits or low disgust. Further research is needed to understand the therapeutic benefits of scary entertainment on mental health and its connection to our dream life. Scary play, including horror movies, can have positive effects on children by teaching them emotion regulation and self-competence, helping them navigate fear in a safe setting. Future research should explore who benefits from morbid curiosity and under what circumstances.
The Fascination with Scary Entertainment
Dr. Colton Scrivener explores our fascination with scary entertainment and the reasons why people enjoy watching horror movies, true crime podcasts, and other types of terrifying genres. Traditional psychology suggests that people enjoy horror films because they are adrenaline junkies, but Dr. Scrivener's research indicates that only a small portion of horror fans fall into this category. Instead, most horror fans are genuinely scared while watching scary content and find it to be a learning experience that helps them develop as individuals. Scary entertainment allows people to feel their fears and understand their limits, ultimately boosting self-confidence to face real-life challenges. Additionally, research shows that horror fans do not lack empathy or exhibit pathological traits. Enjoying horror movies does not indicate a cold-hearted nature or a disregard for others' well-being. True crime podcasts and shows are also enjoyed for similar reasons, offering the opportunity to learn about threats and stimulating the brain's rewards system. While the motivations behind enjoying scary entertainment vary among individuals, learning and personal growth are common themes.
The Morbid Curiosity Scale: Exploring Traits and Characteristics
Dr. Colton Scrivener discusses the Morbid Curiosity Scale and its role in understanding individuals' interest in potentially dangerous things. Morbid curiosity is not strongly correlated with the Big Five personality traits, but research indicates a tendency for higher openness and sometimes higher neuroticism in those with morbid curiosity. The scale has been used to capture people's inherent interest in dangerous and threatening subjects across different cultures. Although there is no direct correlation between morbid curiosity and clinical pathology, further research is necessary to explore the potential associations with other personality traits or beneficial characteristics. Dr. Scrivener believes that studying morbid curiosity can shed light on why humans engage in scary play, how it relates to themes in religion and mythology, and the wide range of entertainment choices people make. He emphasizes the importance of understanding morbid curiosity's impact and its potential benefits and drawbacks in individuals' lives.
Exploring the Impact and Therapeutic Potential
Dr. Colton Scrivener highlights the need for future research on morbid curiosity to understand its impact and therapeutic potential. Scary entertainment, such as horror movies, has been shown to have positive effects on individuals, but the reasons behind different experiences and reactions are still unclear. Research could uncover who benefits from scary content and why, leading to potential therapeutic applications for anxiety, difficult life circumstances, or PTSD. Understanding the connection between morbid curiosity and individuals' dream life is another area of interest, as dreaming and nightmares may be early forms of morbid curiosity. Additionally, exploring why some people find pandemic-related movies too close to home while others find them therapeutic could provide valuable insights for coping with real-life threats. Dr. Scrivener acknowledges that further research in these areas has the potential to impact people's lives and contribute to a deeper understanding of the human fascination with the darker side of life.
October may be the month that our fascination with all things ghoulish and grisly reaches its peak, but for many people, a fascination with the darker side of life isn’t limited to Halloween. Coltan Scrivner, PhD, talks about why people are drawn to horror, true crime and other scary genres; and whether terrifying entertainment can actually be good for some people’s mental health and leave them better equipped to handle real-life challenges. For transcripts, links and more information, please visit the Speaking of Psychology Homepage.