"Alien Says What?" features Brenda, an expert in whale communication and extraterrestrial intelligence. The podcast explores breakthrough research on communicating with humpback whales, discussing their intelligence, complex problem-solving skills, and their own language. They also touch on the implications for communicating with extraterrestrial intelligence and the challenges of studying marine mammals.
The ability to have an extended conversation with a humpback whale suggests the potential for communicating with non-human intelligent species, both on Earth and potentially with aliens in the future.
Applying information theory to study whale communication can help determine the rule structure and carrying capacity of their communication system, and compare it to other species for understanding alien communication.
Understanding the complexity and context of whale vocalizations is a challenge, but studying their diverse social behavior and collaborative interactions can lead to decoding their communication system and appreciating the intelligence of other species on Earth.
Deep dives
Whale communication and its implications
Researchers discuss the study of whale communication and the complexity behind deciphering their messages. They describe an encounter where they had an extended conversation with a humpback whale named Twain, using underwater speakers to play recorded humpback vocalizations. The researchers highlight the importance of understanding the semantics and context of whale communication and the potential it holds for communicating with non-human intelligent species on and off Earth.
The breakthrough in whale communication
A team of researchers claim to have had a breakthrough in communicating with a humpback whale. They provided evidence that the whale understood their recorded calls and engaged in a conversation. This is significant as it sheds light on our ability to communicate with whales and potentially with alien species in the future. The researchers discuss the exchange with the whale, its response to their calls, and the possibilities it presents for further research.
Information theory and measuring complexity
The researchers discuss the use of information theory in studying whale communication. By applying statistical tests and measuring the complexity of whale vocalizations, they aim to determine the rule structure and carrying capacity of the communication system. They compare the complexity of whale communication with that of other species, such as primates and parrots, and the potential implications for understanding alien communication.
Understanding context and intent in whale communication
The researchers delve into the challenge of understanding the context and intent behind whale vocalizations. They explore the diversity and range of vocalizations produced by humpback whales, highlighting their complex social behavior and collaborative interactions. While the researchers aim to decode the meaning of whale communication, they acknowledge the importance of behavioral context and further research to fully understand the intricacies of their communication system.
The significance of communicating with non-human species
The researchers emphasize the significance of communicating with non-human species, such as whales, and the potential for unraveling the intelligence and complex communication systems of other species on Earth. They discuss the conservation value of understanding and appreciating the diverse intelligences present on the planet, highlighting the need for further research and technological advancements to effectively communicate with other species.
Whales are aliens on Earth; intelligent beings who have skills for complex problem-solving and their own language. Now in what’s being called a breakthrough, scientists have carried on an extended conversation with a humpback whale. They share the story of this remarkable encounter, their evidence that the creature understood them, and how the experiment informs our Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence. After all, what good is it to make contact with ET if we can’t communicate?
Guests:
Brenda McCowan – Research behaviorist at the University of California Davis in the School of Veterinary Medicine who studies the ecological aspects of animal behavior and communication.
Fred Sharpe – whale biologist and behavioral ecologist at Simon Fraser University and member of the Templeton Whale SETI Team.
Laurance Doyle – astrophysicist and information theory researcher at the SETI Institute.