Tim Miller, political consultant and writer, discusses the unexpected rise of Mike Johnson as Speaker of the House and his erosion of trust. They also explore the evolution of Republican identity, the rise of Maggah Republicans, and key issues driving the party.
Mike Johnson's election as Speaker of the House highlights the tension between his words about trust and self-governance and his promotion of election denialism and conspiracy theories.
Johnson's extremist views, including opposition to abortion rights, gay rights, and climate change denialism, may pose challenges in moderate districts and harm the party's prospects in future elections.
Deep dives
Mike Johnson Becomes Speaker of the House
Mike Johnson, a relatively unknown congressman from Louisiana, unexpectedly becomes Speaker of the House after weeks of leaderless chaos. Despite his lack of national recognition, Johnson delivers an introductory speech that offers a personal biography and emphasizes the importance of regaining institutional trust. However, critics argue that his actions, such as promoting election denialism and advancing conspiracy theories, contradict his words about trust and self-governance.
Mike Johnson's Background and Ideology
Mike Johnson, a Christian conservative congressman from Louisiana, has been a vocal advocate for social issues and demonstrated his loyalty to former President Donald Trump. With his ability to articulate his views and sound reasonable, Johnson has gained trust from party leadership and the MAGA wing of the Republican Party. However, his extremist views, including support for bans on abortion, opposition to gay rights, climate change denialism, and proposals to slash entitlement programs, may pose challenges in more moderate districts and potentially harm the party's prospects in future elections.
Implications of Johnson's Speakership
While Johnson's election as Speaker may temporarily provide a sense of stability within the Republican Party, it does not signify a resolution to the broader ideological divisions. The election was not based on specific policy positions, but rather a demonstration of power by the MAGA wing over the establishment. Johnson's tenure as Speaker is expected to feature tough negotiations, particularly on issues such as government funding and Ukraine-related matters. Critics express concern over Johnson's potential resistance to compromise due to his past voting records and rigid ideological stances.
Is new House Speaker Mike Johnson a palatable face on the same hard-right politics?
Guest: Tim Miller, political consultant and writer.
If you enjoy this show, please consider signing up for Slate Plus. Slate Plus members get benefits like zero ads on any Slate podcast, bonus episodes of shows like Slow Burn and Dear Prudence—and you’ll be supporting the work we do here on What Next. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to help support our work.