Dan Kois, a seasoned writer at Slate and author of five books, dives into the pressing issues of aviation safety. He discusses the alarming increase in near misses and the systemic challenges faced by air traffic control due to staffing shortages. The conversation critiques the political blame game following recent crashes, questioning Congress's commitment to safety versus convenience. Kois also examines the impact of pilot shortages and calls for a transparent culture in aviation, urging a reevaluation of our societal values regarding safety.
The recent mid-air collision highlighted critical staffing shortages in air traffic control, emphasizing the need for urgent safety improvements.
Political priorities often favor convenience over aviation safety, complicating efforts to address the systemic issues contributing to potential crashes.
Deep dives
Historical Context of Aviation Safety
A significant air disaster occurred recently, which raised alarms due to its rarity, as it had been 15 years since a similar incident. The podcast discusses how experts have been anticipating the likelihood of such an event due to an accumulation of systemic issues in the aviation sector. Many pilots have expressed a sense of foreboding, often feeling that a major crash is inevitable given the alarming number of near misses reported in recent years. This sentiment highlights a deeper concern about the aviation system's preparedness and its failure to address ongoing safety vulnerabilities.
Staffing and Training Challenges
The podcast emphasizes critical shortages in air traffic control staffing as a contributing factor to aviation safety risks. During the recent crash, it was reported that air traffic control was understaffed, leading to one controller managing both airplane and helicopter traffic, which is a demanding responsibility. These staffing issues are not new; they stem from long-standing political neglect and funding shortages that have left air traffic control systems operating with less than the required number of personnel. The training process for air traffic controllers is arduous and lengthy, exacerbating the problem as many quit due to the stress and burnout, further depriving the system of experienced personnel.
Political Inaction and Safety Funding
The conversation around air travel safety is hindered by political dynamics that often prioritize convenience over rigorous safety standards. The podcast notes that congressional advocacy for more flights, without regard to existing capacity constraints, has escalated systemic pressures and risks in aviation. Furthermore, blame is misdirected towards diversity initiatives rather than addressing fundamental issues such as staffing and funding, which are crucial for safety improvements. This political reality creates a dangerous environment where immediate responses are triggered only by crises, rather than proactive measures to enhance aviation safety.
America hadn’t had a major commercial airline crash since 2009 until the mid-air collision over the Potomac. Is this a sign of a larger problem that will require government intervention—and will Congress prioritize safety over convenience for their constituents and themselves?
Want more What Next? Join Slate Plus to unlock full, ad-free access to What Next and all your other favorite Slate podcasts. You can subscribe directly from the What Next show page on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme and Rob Gunther.