The Gollum Effect: When Guarding Research Impedes Progress

In this engaging conversation, historian and philosopher of science Michael Keas analyzes how academic gatekeeping stifles research innovation. He likens the possessive nature of some researchers to Gollum from Tolkien, detailing how this behavior leads to bullying and hampers scientific progress. Keas shares historical insights, including the dynamics between Tycho Brahe and Johannes Kepler. He also addresses the unique hurdles faced by advocates of intelligent design, emphasizing the pressing need for collaboration and open dialogue in academia.