Casey Newton, founder and editor of the technology newsletter Platformer, discusses the spread of misinformation on X during the Israel-Hamas conflict and the impact of Elon Musk's influence. He suggests alternatives to the flawed concept of X as a global town square and highlights the decline in trusted sources on social media platforms like Twitter. The podcast also addresses challenges of content moderation and the viability of alternative platforms.
The lack of content moderation and fact-checking mechanisms on social media platforms has led to the rapid spread of false information and the blurring of the line between real and fake news.
Twitter's credibility has been diminished due to the absence of content moderation, the removal of verification badges from verified journalists, and Elon Musk's focus on transforming the platform into a payment platform and job board.
Deep dives
The Spread of Fake News and Misinformation on Social Media
False videos and misinformation are spreading rapidly on social media platforms, causing confusion and blurring the line between real and fake news. With the rise of social media platforms, the responsibility of content moderation has diminished, leading to the dissemination of false information. The lack of verification and fact-checking mechanisms on these platforms has created a breeding ground for misinformation to thrive. Elon Musk's influence on the platform has further compounded the problem, as he has eliminated content moderation teams and endorsed accounts known for spreading misinformation. The consequences of these actions are dire, as social media platforms that were once reliable sources of news have now become inundated with misleading and false content.
The Decline of Twitter as a News Platform
Twitter, once a reliable source for real-time news and information, has lost its credibility due to the lack of content moderation and the proliferation of false content. The removal of verification badges from verified journalists and the selling of these badges to users for a fee has contributed to the erosion of trust. Elon Musk's disregard for content moderation and his focus on transforming Twitter into a payment platform and job board has resulted in the platform losing its status as a reliable news source. As a result, users are questioning the usefulness and value of Twitter as a platform for news consumption.
The Role of Threads in Filling the Void
Threads, a text-based social network by Meta, has emerged as an alternative platform for discussions about news and current events. While it does not amplify news content, it has become a hub for journalists, experts, and regular users to engage in conversations and share information. Threads aims to recreate the vibrant and real-time news discussions that were once a hallmark of platforms like Twitter. It provides an opportunity for regular people to express their thoughts and for journalists to share insights without the noise and misinformation that plagues other platforms. While it is still evolving, Threads offers a potential solution for those seeking meaningful conversations around news and events.
The Future of the Social Web
The social web is undergoing a transformation with the decentralization of platforms and the emergence of new alternatives. While the concentration of power in a few social media giants is dissipating, there is now a proliferation of smaller platforms catering to different niche interests and communities. This diversification of platforms offers individuals more choices and opportunities to express their opinions and engage in conversations. While some may lament the loss of the old social media order, it also presents an opportunity to rethink and redefine what social media can be. The future of the social web lies in a more decentralized, user-driven landscape.
When the Arab Spring was unfolding, Twitter was hailed as a way for on-the-ground reporting to reach the public. But when fighting between Hamas and Israel broke out over the weekend, X became flooded with misinformation.
Guest: Casey Newton, founder and editor of the technology newsletter Platformer.
If you enjoy this show, please consider signing up for Slate Plus. Slate Plus members get benefits like zero ads on any Slate podcast, bonus episodes of shows like Slow Burn and Dear Prudence—and you’ll be supporting the work we do here on What Next TBD. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to help support our work.