Beauty: A Very Short Introduction by Roger Scruton
Mar 21, 2023
auto_awesome
Roger Scruton, philosopher and author of Beauty: A Very Short Introduction, discusses taste judgments, his reputation, and the disappointment with his book. The chapter also explores the concept of beauty from an evolutionary perspective and critiques Scruton's work. The podcast ends with a discussion on the differences between Western and non-Western concepts of history.
Scruton argues that beauty is anchored in reason and that art must have meaning.
The book lacks clear explanations, comprehensive analysis, and is filled with convoluted prose.
Deep dives
Roger Scruton's Short Introduction to Aesthetics
The podcast episode discusses Roger Scruton's book 'Beauty: A Very Short Introduction,' which aims to explore the concept of beauty. The hosts find the book challenging to comprehend, as Scruton's writing style is dense and filled with abstract references. They criticize the lack of a clear thesis or argument, making it difficult to discern his views on beauty. However, they note that Scruton argues that beauty is anchored in reason and that art must have meaning. They also discuss his disdain for kitsch and his negative views on the impact of photography on art. Overall, the hosts find the book frustrating and inaccessible, struggling to extract meaningful insights from its contents.
The Frustration with Scruton's Writing Style
The hosts express their struggle with understanding Scruton's writing style in his book. They find his prose filled with convoluted paragraphs and vague references, which make it hard to follow his arguments or discern his main points. The hosts mention the book's tendency to make offhand allusions and references to obscure works of art, assuming reader familiarity, and the frustration of reading what they perceive as jargon-filled art criticism. They criticize the book's lack of clear explanations and comprehensive analysis, leaving them feeling lost and unable to grasp the intended meaning behind Scruton's statements.
Scruton's Views on Beauty and Critique of Kitsch
The hosts discuss some of Scruton's views on beauty, noting his belief that it is a universal value tied to reason. They mention his argument that art must have meaning and his disdain for kitsch, which he sees as a world of commodities rather than revered icons. They touch upon Scruton's negative views on the impact of photography on art, suggesting that he believes photography lacks the expressive and intentional qualities that make art meaningful. Despite finding Scruton's depiction of beauty and his critiques interesting, the hosts feel that his lack of clarity and excessive use of abstract concepts hinder their ability to fully engage with and comprehend his ideas.