No Sanity Required Why I Left the Catholic Faith
Aug 12, 2025
Brody and John dive deep into faith as John recounts his journey from a devout Catholic upbringing to embracing Protestantism. They discuss the strengths and struggles of both traditions, exploring church authority and Bible interpretation. The conversation highlights Augustine's theology on grace and faith, revealing personal reflections on religious studies. Additionally, they tackle the complexities of legalism and authority, and touch on emerging interests in Catholicism among youth seeking truth amid cultural uncertainty.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Growing Up Devout Catholic
- John grew up devoutly Catholic in Atlanta with a strong family and parish life.
- He describes shifting youth-group experiences that reignited his faith and questions in high school.
Small Group Bible Study Changed Everything
- John joined a Protestant youth group and learned active Bible interpretation in a small group setting.
- A youth pastor assigned verses and had students present their findings, which transformed John's approach to Scripture.
Reform Not Replacement
- Luther viewed his Reformation as reforming the existing church rather than creating a new one.
- He believed Christ's church remains holy by God's action even when human leaders fail.
