Former State Department official, Josh Paul, shares his decision to resign over US arms sales to Israel. He discusses the moral complexities in his role, lack of accountability and debate, and the need for a course correction in US foreign policy towards Israel.
Josh Paul resigned from the State Department due to concerns about civilian harm caused by US arms transfers during the Israel-Gaza conflict, highlighting the need for accountability.
Paul's resignation highlights the importance of following US government rules on arms transfers and demanding equal standards for accountability and human rights in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Deep dives
Josh Paul resigns from State Department over arms transfer policy
Josh Paul, a former diplomat with the State Department, recently resigned from his position to protest the US government's arms transfers during the conflict between Israel and Hamas. In a strongly-worded resignation letter, Paul expressed his concerns about the civilian harm caused by the US-provided arms and criticized the American response to the war. He had worked in the Bureau of Political Military Affairs, facilitating international weapons transfers. Israel, as a major recipient of American weapons, had requested additional arms after a recent attack by Hamas. Paul disagreed with his superiors' willingness to fulfill this request, leading to his resignation
Paul's decision reflects moral considerations and a need for accountability
Josh Paul's decision to resign was motivated by his moral concerns and a desire for accountability. He acknowledged the moral complexity of working for the US government but felt that the American response to the conflict was making the situation worse. Paul believed that his role allowed him to influence decisions related to human rights and mitigate potential negative outcomes. However, the lack of debate and the disregard for the US government's own rules on arms transfers prompted him to take a stand
The impact of Paul's resignation and the need for course correction
Since his resignation, Josh Paul has received support from colleagues in various government agencies and uniformed military personnel. He has also noted a tempering of the US government's initial response to the conflict. However, Paul acknowledges that the arms transfers are still ongoing, and he remains skeptical about whether the US administration will hold Israel accountable for potential human rights violations. He calls for a deeper examination of US foreign policy towards the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and urges a shift towards following the US government's own rules for arms transfers and demanding equal standards for accountability and human rights
Why one State Department official who worked in weapons transfers quit over America’s policy towards Israel and Gaza—and what that says about U.S. policy in the Middle East.
Guest: Josh Paul, former State Department official working in arms transfers to foreign powers, who resigned on Oct. 18.
If you enjoy this show, please consider signing up for Slate Plus. Slate Plus members get benefits like zero ads on any Slate podcast, bonus episodes of shows like Slow Burn and Dear Prudence—and you’ll be supporting the work we do here on What Next. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to help support our work.