Chuck’s Commentary - What If 9/11 Never Happened? + College Football Playoff Reaction
The Chuck ToddCast
How DHS evolved into immigration focus
Todd describes the Department of Homeland Security's origins and how it became centered on immigration enforcement.
In this episode of the Chuck ToddCast, Chuck tackles one of the most consequential counterfactuals in modern history: what if 9/11 never happened? He explores how the attacks fundamentally altered the American psyche, shattered a post–Cold War sense of security, and transformed how Americans consume news, driving the demand for instant information and accelerating the technologies that now dominate our lives. The conversation examines how U.S. politics, foreign policy, and polarization might have evolved without the War on Terror—no Patriot Act, no Department of Homeland Security, no Iraq War—and whether the political forces that produced figures like Trump and Obama would have emerged at all. From global relationships with Russia and China to the delayed reckoning over economic inequality and partisan division, this episode traces the ripple effects of an event that reshaped everything, and asks what might have filled the vacuum if it had never occurred.
Finally, Chuck reacts to his Miami Hurricanes upsetting Ohio State in the college football playoff and makes his predictions for the upcoming games.
Thank you Wildgrain for sponsoring. Visit http://wildgrain.com/TODDCAST and use the code "TODDCAST" at checkout to receive $30 off your first box PLUS free Croissants for life!
Timeline:
(Timestamps may vary based on advertisements)
00:00 Chuck Todd’s introduction
03:00 “What if” 9/11 never happened?
03:45 9/11 changed how Americans consumed information
04:30 9/11 was the first true “hit” on the homeland
05:30 9/11 create a new sense of vulnerability in America
06:45 The trauma from 9/11 changed the American psyche
08:45 Prior to 9/11, America was living in a post cold-war calm
09:30 In 2000, the west was trying to court Russia into joining them
10:15 Both parties will bullish on integrating China into the world
11:45 Bush would have been more western hemisphere focused
12:45 Without 9/11, Washington would have been more polarized
13:45 The Bush presidency essentially began on 9/11
15:30 9/11 triggered a “need” for immediate information
16:30 Social media is created to provide immediate info
17:15 There’s no Patriot Act, Iraq war, War on Terror without 9/11
18:30 There would be no Department of Homeland Security
19:45 Homeland Security eventually became an immigration agency
21:45 The isolationist strain of MAGA may not materialize
23:15 Some of the responses to 9/11 led to rise of MAGA politics
25:00 9/11 created a new sense of urgency for following the news
26:15 9/11 sped up the adoption of new information technologies
28:15 Do we not have Trump or Obama without hyper-engaged politics?
29:00 John Kerry probably isn’t the nominee in 2004 without 9/11
30:30 What replaces 9/11 if it never happened?
30:45 Financial crisis still happens anyways
31:45 9/11 delayed the “uniparty reckoning”
32:45 Occupy Wall Street would supplant Tea Party as driving force in 2010
34:00 Without Iraq War, there’s less distinction between Clinton & Obama
35:30 9/11 delayed polarization, economic issues by a few years
37:30 “If 9/11 never happened” final conclusions
40:30 “What Ifs” left on the cutting room floor
49:15 Chuck’s college football playoff reaction
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
The AI-powered Podcast Player
