
The Struggle to Be Honest: Truth, Lies, AI, and Humanity / Christian B. Miller
For the Life of the World / Yale Center for Faith & Culture
Technology, Accountability, and Broken Trust
Evan Rosa and Christian Miller connect technological progress with eroding relationships, weakened accountability, and sermon plagiarism enabled by the internet and AI.
Honesty may be the virtue we prize most in other people, and it is eroding fast. Philosopher Christian B. Miller, A. C. Reid Professor of Philosophy at Wake Forest University and author of The Honesty Crisis, argues that we are living through not one honesty crisis but several at once, each driven by new technologies that make dishonesty more tempting and harder to catch.
In this episode with Evan Rosa, Miller unpacks what has actually changed: why AI cheating feels efficient, effective, and evasive to students who assume everyone else is doing it; how sermon plagiarism moved from borrowed manuscripts to the internet to AI; and how celebrity culture, at every scale from pop stars to local pastors, widens the gap between a curated public image and a private self.
Together they discuss honesty as far more than truth-telling, a virtue that covers cheating, stealing, misleading, BS-ing, and self-deception, along with Miller’s definition of honest behavior as not intentionally misrepresenting or distorting the facts as you see them, which frees honesty from any claim to possess capital-T Truth. Together they also consider why we are neither born nor raised honest, why honest motivation has to be other-centered rather than reward-seeking, how hard reality, trusted friends, and the Holy Spirit can break through self-deception, how rampant dishonesty leaves a society transactional and afraid, and why, in a fallen world with a Nazi at the door, honesty can be outweighed by compassion and justice.
Episode Highlights
- ”So when you put those two together, greater temptation and also easier to get away with it, that’s a bad combination. It’s a bad formula for trying to preserve what I think is our most important virtue of honesty.”
- ”We have something that’s efficient, effective, evasive, and everyone else is thought to be using it.”
- ”I think it’s now we’ve gone so far, there’s no going back … we cannot assume that graded work in education at the middle school, high school, undergraduate, and graduate levels is actually, predominantly the work of the student as opposed to the work of an AI.”
- ”According to some survey data I’ve seen, at least 25% of pastors are using AI for sermon writing and preparation without acknowledgement. And so they’re standing up there presenting this material as if it were their own.”
- ”What I want to say is honest behavior is a matter of not intentionally misrepresenting or distorting the facts as you see them.”
- ”3,000 years ago, when people were saying the Earth is flat, they were wrong, but they weren’t dishonest.”
- ”Most people want to cheat if they think they can get away with it, and it’s suitably beneficial.”
- ”This is not just the Taylor Swifts, this is not just the LeBron Jameses of the world, massive celebrities. We are all celebrities to some extent.”
- ”You are unable to form genuine friendships and loving, caring relationships with anyone, because those presuppose trust and honesty, and dishonesty breaks down trust, and fractures the relationship… And instead, what ends up happening is you live in fear.”
- ”In these tragic, terrible situations, we have to balance honesty, which is important, with other values like compassion, kindness, caring, justice… Honesty is really important, but it’s not the only thing that matters.”
About Christian B. Miller
Christian B. Miller is the A. C. Reid Professor of Philosophy at Wake Forest University, where he studies virtue and moral character. He directed The Honesty Project, a $4.4 million initiative funded by the John Templeton Foundation, and earlier led The Character Project. He is the author of more than 130 articles and several books, including The Character Gap: How Good Are We?, Honesty: The Philosophy and Psychology of a Neglected Virtue, and, most recently, The Honesty Crisis: Preserving Our Most Treasured Virtue in an Increasingly Dishonest World (2026). He lives in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, with his wife and three children.
Helpful Links and Resources
- The Honesty Crisis: Preserving Our Most Treasured Virtue in an Increasingly Dishonest World, Christian B. Miller: https://christianbmiller.com/the-honesty-crisis/
- The Character Gap: How Good Are We?, Christian B. Miller: https://christianbmiller.com/the-character-gap/
- About Christian B. Miller: https://christianbmiller.com/about-me/
- The Honesty Project, Wake Forest University: https://honestyproject.philosophy.wfu.edu
- On Bullshit, Harry G. Frankfurt: https://press.princeton.edu/books/ebook/9780691276793/on-bullshit-0
- Honesty is the first chapter in the book of wisdom, Thomas Jefferson: https://www.monticello.org/encyclopedia/honesty-first-chapter-book-wisdom/
- “Lying and Speaking Your Interlocutor’s Language,” Alexander R. Pruss: https://muse.jhu.edu/article/637086/pdf
Show Notes
- The honesty crisis
- Not one crisis but several, each pairing greater temptation with easier escape from detection
- Technology as the cause, though not inherently evil
- Crib notes, honor codes, and the internet
- AI cheating
- Four drivers of student AI use: speed, polish, near-undetectability, and assuming everyone else does it
- No going back on assuming graded work reflects a student’s own effort
- Technological advance as relational decline and eroded accountability
- Sermon plagiarism, from borrowed manuscripts to online sermons to AI
- Pastors using AI without acknowledgment, and the broken trust when it surfaces
- Lying, cheating, stealing, misleading, fraud, self-deception, and BS-ing
- Harry Frankfurt’s On Bullshit
- Deepfakes, AI companions, infidelity websites, and misinformation
- Honest behavior defined by the facts as you see them, not capital-T Truth
- Flat-earth believers, the Matrix, and trusting experts who let us down
- Most people cheat when it pays and detection seems unlikely
- Not born honest, not raised honest
- Winnicott’s false self and early incentives to hide
- Why honest motives must be other-centered, not self-protective
- Celebrity culture, curated public images, and feeling above the rules
- Everyone with a platform, down to the local pastor, as a minor celebrity
- Jefferson on honesty and wisdom
- Self-deception
- Downplaying unwelcome evidence about a partner, or about ourselves
- Hitting bottom, trusted friends, and the Holy Spirit as ways through
- Ephesians 4:25 (NIV): "Therefore each of you must put off falsehood and speak truthfully to your neighbor, for we are all members of one body."
- A dishonest society as transactional, friendless, and afraid
- The Nazi at the door, when compassion and justice outweigh honesty
- Alexander Pruss on lying
- Preserving valuable connections at the cost of corrupted ones
#ForTheLifeOfTheWorld #Honesty #HonestyCrisis #AIEthics #AcademicIntegrity #MoralPsychology #Virtue #Philosophy #ChristianEthics #Podcast
Production Notes
- This podcast featured Christian B. Miller
- Edited and Produced by Evan Rosa
- Hosted by Evan Rosa
- Production Assistance by Noah Senthil
- A Production of the Yale Center for Faith & Culture at Yale Divinity School https://faith.yale.edu/about
- Support For the Life of the World podcast by giving to the Yale Center for Faith & Culture: https://faith.yale.edu/give


