
The Lead Nurture Email Playbook: What Works and What Doesn’t
The Exit Five CMO Podcast (Hosted by Dave Gerhardt)
Intro
This chapter dives into effective lead nurturing email strategies essential for B2B marketing. Experts discuss best practices and analyze real-life email examples to help marketers improve engagement and conversion rates.
#247 Lead Nurturing | In this episode, Danielle is joined by Samar Owais, founder of Emails Done Right; Sheri Otto, CEO of Growth Lane Strategies; and Sofia Silva, Marketing Manager at Reachdesk.
These three email experts came together for a live roast of real B2B lead nurture emails, submitted by marketers from the Exit Five community. You’ll hear the good, the bad, and the fixable, with practical insights on how to improve your own nurture sequences.
Danielle, Samar, Sheri, and Sofia cover:
- The most common lead nurture mistakes B2B marketers make (and how to fix them)
- Why every email should be treated as a conversation, not just a campaign
- How to write nurture emails that create connection, not clicks for clicks’ sake
If you're building (or rebuilding) your nurture strategy, this one’s packed with real examples and expert feedback to guide your next send.
Timestamps
- (00:00) - – Intro: Welcome to the Lead Nurture Roast
- (03:16) - – Meet the Experts: Samar, Sheri, and Sofia
- (07:13) - – What Is **Lead Nurturing, Really?
- (10:06) - – The Problem with “We” Language in Emails
- (12:28) - – The Biggest Mistakes B2B Marketers Make
- (14:53) - – Why AI Isn’t Your Copywriter
- (16:48) - – Teardown #1: Subject Line Gone Wrong
- (21:18) - – How to Build a Nurture Sequence Around a Whitepaper
- (23:58) - – CTA Overload and Why It Kills Clicks
- (29:27) - – Teardown #2: Great Open Rate, Low Engagement
- (33:21) - – The One-CTA Rule (And Why It Matters)
- (36:03) - – Structuring Long Emails for Skimmability
- (38:35) - – Teardown #3: Cold Lead, Wrong Email
- (41:08) - – Re-Engagement Emails That Actually Work
- (43:58) - – Use Social Proof Instead of Product Pitches
- (45:38) - – Teardown #4: The Overloaded Onboarding Email
- (48:33) - – What’s a “Micro Conversion” in SaaS Email?
- (53:08) - – Time-to-Value and the First Action That Matters
- (55:23) - – This Email Is... a Whole Sequence in One
- (57:43) - – Teardown #5: Trust Email or Generic Spam?
- (01:00:38) - – Why Specificity Beats Industry Buzzwords
- (01:02:53) - – Final Scores and Wrap-Up
Send guest pitches and ideas to hi@exitfive.com
Join the Exit Five Newsletter here: https://www.exitfive.com/newsletter
Check out the Exit Five job board: https://jobs.exitfive.com/
Become an Exit Five member: https://community.exitfive.com/checkout/exit-five-membership
***
Today’s episode is brought to you by Walnut.
Why are we pouring all this effort into marketing just to push buyers to a “request a demo” or “contact sales” button?
Come on, today’s buyers don’t want to talk to sales right away. They want to explore your product themselves, see how it works, and understand its value before booking a meeting.
That’s where Walnut comes in.
Walnut empowers marketers and GTM teams to create interactive, self-guided product experiences in minutes. Embed these experiences on your site, in emails, or anywhere in your funnel to let buyers engage on their terms, from awareness to close and beyond.
That's the beauty of Walnut - you're getting a platform that your sales and CS colleagues can use to showcase the product too.
And the best part? You get real intent data—see which features prospects love, where they drop off, and what’s actually driving pipeline. Demo Qualified Leads are the new MQL.
Over 500 companies, like Adobe and NetApp, use Walnut to drive 2-3x higher website conversion rates and 7 figures in pipeline on a yearly basis. So do you want to drive more leads, shorten sales cycles, and actually show your product instead of hiding it behind another typical B2B CTA?
Go check out Walnut.io. And if you tell them Dave from Exit 5 sent you, they'll build out your first demo for free!