390: What Managers Need to Know Before Hiring a Friend with Dr. Cindi Baldi
The Modern Manager
Mitigating perception of favoritism
They recommend stepping out of hiring decisions or delegating assessment to avoid conflict-of-interest perceptions.
Hiring a friend can feel both generous and like a leadership landmine waiting to explode.
Good intentions aren’t enough when power dynamics shift, boundaries blur, and personal relationships collide with professional expectations. The risk isn’t just losing a friendship; it’s undermining trust, fairness, and team culture if the situation isn’t handled thoughtfully.
Fortunately, this week’s guest helps us unpack how to navigate one of leadership’s most uncomfortable decisions with clarity and integrity.
Dr. Cindi Baldi is the founder and CEO of Culsure, a management science firm, co-host of the Management Muse podcast, and co-author of the Uncertainty Playbook. From blackjack dealer to PhD in organizational behavior, Cindi has seen the full spectrum of workplace behavior. Now she helps leaders across the country understand their people better through data and decades of consulting experience. Cindy explains when hiring a friend can work, when it absolutely won’t, and how to protect both the relationship and the organization if you decide to move forward.
You’ll learn how to say no to a friend without damaging the relationship, what boundaries must be set upfront if you do hire them, and why conflict style in friendships is a strong predictor of workplace behavior.
In the extended conversation, Cindy goes deeper into the hidden risks of managing friends, including what must be off-limits once a friend reports to you, how oversharing personal information can undermine fairness and trust, and how to lead with integrity when professional and personal lines start to blur.
Get FREE mini-episode guides with the big idea from the week’s episode delivered to your inbox when you subscribe to my weekly email.
Join the conversation now!
Conversation Topics
- (00:00) The hidden risks and rewards of hiring a friend
- (03:03) Why friendships change once power dynamics enter the picture
- (06:00) Using social capital responsibly when recommending friends
- (12:42) What you can legitimately vouch for when referring someone
- (15:11) When hiring a friend actually makes strategic sense
- (17:03) The bias trap leaders fall into with people they like
- (20:25) How to protect fairness when making the hiring decision
- (22:36) Setting expectations before your friend starts the job
- (27:02) Power dynamics that make hiring a friend a bad idea
- (30:31) [Extended Episode Only] What to do when your friend applies but isn’t a good fit
- (36:29) [Extended Episode Only] Preventing personal boundaries from bleeding into work
📚 Additional Resources:
✨Get the extended episode by joining The Modern Manager Podcast+ Community for just $15 per month
✨ Read the full transcript: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1bDdd0ol67WBTmohak12Nyi8XKXUOvWjVWfG4edyXDvo/edit?usp=sharing
✨Follow me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mamieks/
✨Visit my website for more: https://www.mamieks.com/
✨Upskill your team: https://themodernmanager.com/replaybundle
✨Subscribe to my YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC7jhYz8b16g1SsLia4EhO5w?sub_confirmation=1
Keep up with Cindi Baldi
🔸 Connect with Cindi on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/cindibaldi
🔸 Follow Management Muse on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/management-muse-podcast/
🔸 Subscribe to Management Muse on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/ManagementMusePodcast
🔸 Follow Management Muse on Instagram: https://instagram.com/managementmuse
🔸 Follow Management Muse on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/managementmusepodcast
Guest Bonus: 3 Book Giveaway: The Uncertainty Playbook: 14 Strategies for Work Success in a Chaotic World
There is a blizzard of uncertainty—technological, geopolitical, demographic, climate-related, and more—impacting us at work today, and it is only accelerating. Drawing on two decades of research and practice by organizational scientists Geoffrey Tumlin and Cindi Baldi, this book equips readers with essential strategies to grow and even flourish in unstable times.
To get this bonus and many other member benefits, become a member of The Modern Manager Podcast+ Community.
---------------------
The Modern Manager is a leadership podcast for rockstar managers who want to create a working environment where people thrive and great work gets done.
Follow The Modern Manager on your favorite podcast platform so you won’t miss an episode!
The AI-powered Podcast Player
