Jurisdiction and Federalism: The Framers' Dilemma

This chapter explores the complexities of legal jurisdiction and the role of the Supreme Court in shaping state laws, particularly through the lens of Justice Sotomayor's case. It examines the historical context of federalism in the U.S., including the framers' intentions in crafting the Constitution and their challenges in balancing power among various government levels. Additionally, it discusses James Madison's proposals for federal oversight on state legislation and imagines the potential outcomes had his ideas been fully implemented.