Why Tidy First? Questioning Tidying

Kent Beck: You’re Ignoring Optionality… and Paying for It

In this episode of Maintainable, Robby speaks with Kent Beck, a foundational voice in modern software development and author of Tidy First?. Kent joins from California to explore why optionality is a central, often underestimated dimension of maintainable software.

Kent begins by describing the tension between features and future flexibility. Shipping new capabilities is easy to measure. Creating options for what comes next is not. That imbalance is where maintainability either flourishes or collapses. Senior developers in particular must learn to navigate this tension because they have lived through the consequences when no one does.

They reflect on how cost models have shifted across the last five decades. Early in Kent’s career, computers were expensive and programmers were cheap. Today the balance often flips depending on scale. At massive scale, electricity and compute time become meaningful costs again. That variability shapes whether teams optimize for hardware efficiency or developer efficiency.

Episode Highlights

[00:00:46] The Two Forms of Software Value

Kent explains why software value comes from both current features and the options you preserve for future work. He describes optionality as the invisible half of maintainability.

[00:03:35] When Computers Become “Expensive” Again

Robby and Kent revisit the shift from hardware-optimized development to developer-optimized development and how large-scale systems have reintroduced compute cost pressures.

[00:07:25] Why the Question Mark in Tidy First?

Kent shares why tidying is always a judgment call and why he put a question mark in the title.

[00:10:14] The Real Cost of Speculative Flexibility

They discuss why adding configurability too early creates waste and why waiting until just before you need it increases value.

[00:13:46] Making Hard Changes Easy

Kent outlines his guiding idea. When you face a difficult change, make the change easy first, then make the easy change.

[00:17:08] The Feature Saw

Kent explains his features versus options graph and how teams repeatedly burn optionality until they hit zero. At that point, forward movement becomes painful.

[00:19:37] Why 100 Percent Utilization Is a Trap

Kent discusses how queuing theory shows that full utilization pushes wait times toward infinity. Overcommitted teams have no room for design work.

[00:22:44] Split Teams Do Not Solve the Problem

Robby talks about consulting scenarios where “tidy teams” and “feature teams” are separated. Kent argues that this splits incentives and prevents optionality from being sustained.

[00:26:15] Structure and Behavior Should Not Ship Together

Kent describes why feature changes are irreversible, structure changes are reversible, and why combining them increases risk for everyone.

[00:30:37] Tidying Reveals Intent

While cleaning up structure, developers often uncover logic flaws or misunderstandings that were previously hidden.

[00:32:00] When Teams Discourage Testing

Kent shares stories about environments where developers were punished for refactoring or writing tests. He explains why building career options is essential in those situations.

[00:37:57] Why Tidying Is an Ethical Obligation

Kent reframes optionality as a moral responsibility. No one should make work harder for the next person who touches the code.

[00:41:33] Succession and Slicing

Kent describes how nearly every structural change can be broken into small, safe steps, even when the change first appears atomic.

[00:47:00] A Small Habit to Start Today

Kent suggests adding a blank line to separate conceptual chunks in long functions. It is a small step that improves clarity immediately.

Resources Mentioned

• Tidy First? by Kent Beck
• Kent Beck on Substack
• The Timeless Way of Building by Christopher Alexander

Thanks to Our Sponsor!

Turn hours of debugging into just minutes! AppSignal is a performance monitoring and error-tracking tool designed for Ruby, Elixir, Python, Node.js, Javascript, and other frameworks.

It offers six powerful features with one simple interface, providing developers with real-time insights into the performance and health of web applications.

Keep your coding cool and error-free, one line at a time! 

Use the code maintainable to get a 10% discount for your first year. Check them out!

Subscribe to Maintainable on:

• Apple Podcasts
• Spotify

Or search "Maintainable" wherever you stream your podcasts.

Keep up to date with the Maintainable Podcast by joining the newsletter.