The New Year's Eve of 2014

Marina Bolter of Bloomfield, Indiana disappeared on New Year's Eve 2014. The 18-year-old had been dating a young man named DJ Lockhart for some time and they were very much in love. But she was also seeing an older married man called Toby who acted as something of a sugar daddy to Marina until she could afford her own apartment. And it turns out that he is the husband of one of his friends' infidelities. Many have speculated thatDJ may be responsible but others say him only guilty because he loved Marina too much.