The Genetic Fallacy of James White

James White loves to quote liberal Catholic scholars to make his arguments against Catholicism. Even if Poirier is wrong about the authorship of the pastoral letters, that doesn't mean he's wrong about the meaning of Thaobnustos. The next time someone says Second Timothy 3 16 shows solo scriptura is true, it does not prove scripture is the only infallible rule of faith. To reach that conclusion, you have to overextend the biblical evidence and make assumptions that are simply unwarranted.