The Dilemma of Sherry Papini

Sherry Papini had always described her captors bathroom as having a unique layout. The detectives showed her some photos of bathrooms with similar designs to the ones she'd described. Sherry acknowledged the layouts were similar, but that was all. She'd previously said there was a crack in the shower tile. Investigators searched through social media on an account owned by James Reyes' brother. They found a picture of a coffee table that looked exactly like the one Sherry had described being tied to while she was branded. A check of his background revealed no major criminal record, save for a drunk driving charge.