On the surface, emergency funds sound like a very prudent idea. You set aside cash for unknowable, unforseeable events so that you aren't strapped when you really need it. We're not disagreeing with the idea, but an emergency fund is somewhat counter to the core principle of YNAB: giving every dollar a job. In an emergency fund, dollars are given a job, but it's a vague one.
Jesse likens it to a football coach yelling at his defense to "just stop the other team from scoring!" The coach is identifying the basic goal of the game, but there's nothing specific to help the players actually accomplish that task. A good coach instead instructs players what to do at an individual level, adjusting their positioning, technique, key reads etc. so that they can more effectively play their role on the team. The net result is the same -- stopping the other team from scoring -- but the results are far more effective.
The same is true with your dollars. While yes, we do want to set aside money for larger, less frequent expenses, the truth is many of these expenses are knowable, we just don't plan for them. New roof, new tires, plumbing repair, etc. Including these items into your plan and saving for them accomplishes what the emergency fund accomplishes, but with more clarity.
So, consider just deleting your emergency fund. Or at least make it smaller, and give those dollars more specific, effective jobs.
Watch The Jesse Mecham Show on Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/@jessemechamshow
Got a question for Jesse? Send him an email:
askjesse@ynab.com
Sign up for a free 34-day trial of YNAB at www.youneedabudget.com
Follow YNAB on social media:
Facebook: @ynabofficial
Instagram: @ynab.official
Twitter/X: @ynab
Tik Tok: @ynabofficial
Tickets to YNAB Fan Fest 2025 are on sale now! Coming to San Diego, Minneapolis, and NYC:
YNAB.com/events
