Exploring AI's Role in Spiritual Leadership

Artificial intelligence is already reshaping how some pastors write sermons, lead meetings, and care for people—but what are the theological and ethical boundaries for its use in ministry? In this wide-ranging conversation, Mike Neglia speaks with Dr Paul Hoffman about the promises and perils of AI for preachers and church leaders. Together they explore the difference between narrow and general AI, how it can streamline administrative work, and why it should never replace the Spirit-led work of sermon preparation. This thoughtful exchange offers both caution and clarity for pastors navigating technology in a rapidly changing world.

Together, they explore the difference between general and narrow AI, where it can be useful in pastoral ministry (meeting prep, research, organising sermon notes), and where it poses serious spiritual and ethical concerns (outsourcing sermon writing, shortcuts in discipleship). Paul makes a passionate case for the irreplaceable role of the preacher’s soul in interpreting and applying God’s Word—and warns against any technological solution that would diminish that.

Mike and Paul also talk about the pastoral and educational implications of AI use, including issues of plagiarism, critical thinking, spiritual formation, and the need for deep wisdom in an age of endless information. You’ll hear reflections on how AI can help—and how it might hinder—our calling to shepherd people toward Christlikeness.

If you’re a pastor, Bible teacher, student, or church leader wrestling with how to navigate new tech wisely, this episode will offer clarity, caution, and encouragement.

👤 About Dr Paul Hoffman

Dr Paul A. Hoffman (PhD, University of Manchester) is the lead pastor of Evangelical Friends Church of Newport, Rhode Island, where he has served since 2007. He is also an adjunct professor at Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary and Regent University School of Divinity, and is deeply involved in the Evangelical Homiletics Society, where he serves as co-chair of the Haddon W. Robinson Biblical Preaching Award.

Paul’s ministry is marked by a commitment to reconciliation, unity, and revival. He regularly teaches and writes on preaching, theology, and the role of the church in today’s complex cultural landscape.

Connect with Paul:
Facebook – https://www.facebook.com/pastorhoffman
Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/pastorhoffman
Twitter/X – https://twitter.com/pastorhoffman77

📚 Resources & Books Mentioned

• AI Shepherds and Their Digital Sheep: Christian Reflections on the Technological Future by Paul Hoffman & Sean O’Callaghan
  https://www.amazon.com/AI-Shepherds-Their-Digital-Sheep/dp/1666775074
• The Freedom of Self-Forgetfulness by Tim Keller
  https://www.thegoodbook.com/the-freedom-of-self-forgetfulness
• The Age of AI: And Our Human Future by Henry Kissinger, Eric Schmidt, and Daniel Huttenlocher
  https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/705709/the-age-of-ai-by-henry-a-kissinger-eric-schmidt-and-daniel-huttenlocher
• Logos Bible Software (AI-powered Bible study and research tools)
  https://www.logos.com
• Otter.ai (transcription and meeting summary tool)
  https://otter.ai
• Canva (AI-assisted visual design platform)
  https://www.canva.com
• Lectio Divina (a method of prayerful, contemplative Scripture reading)
  https://www.crosswalk.com/faith/spiritual-life/what-is-lectio-divina.html
• 📚 Preaching to a Divided Nation by Paul A. Hoffman & Matthew D. Kim
  https://www.amazon.com/dp/1540964744

🎧 Subscribe, rate, and review the podcast to help more pastors grow in their personal study and public proclamation of God’s Word.

For information about our upcoming training events visit ExpositorsCollective.com 

The Expositors Collective podcast is part of the CGNMedia, Working together to proclaim the Gospel, make disciples, and plant churches. For more content like this, visit https://cgnmedia.org/