Process matters: desire for transparent FDA review

A couple of weeks ago, the FDA Commissioner published a WSJ oped “The FDA Liberates Women’s Hormone Replacement Therapy” (←gift link) and, with other FDA colleagues, a JAMA essay entitled “Updated Labeling for Menopausal Hormone Therapy” (open-access). That change, and the data cited, led to a series of articles in the days that followed, such as at STAT News “FDA reverses decades-old warning on hormone therapy products for menopause. Agency says the treatments o!fer heart, brain, and bone health benefits” and at the Washington Post “The FDA finally corrects its error on menopause hormone therapy. Women have been needlessly scared away from effective treatments.” If you read through these links, you’ll be confused. Does MHT have proven cognitive benefits? What about a study from 1991 that showed ~50% reduction of fatal heart events with MHT? Or the 35% decreased risk of Alzheimer’s disease? Or the breast cancer increased risk attributed to medroxyprogesterone acetate?

I turned to my go-to gynecologist truth teller, Dr. Jen Gunter, to get her review of the evidence. This is a complex topic, with old data from the 2002 Women’s Heath Initiative (WHI), new reports since, population level analysis, changes in preparations of MHT including local delivery, and much more.

Here is our conversation which isn’t just about MHT but includes “Big Wellness” marketing direct to middle aged women, the new FDA approved drug for hot flashes, the $14 million cut of the NIH’s Office of Women’s Health , marked increase in philanthropic support of women’s health research, the Surgeon General nominee, ovarian failure, and a lightning round on proven benefits of MHT.

Here’s a brief clip on her views of the women’s health “wellness” predators

We also discussed the reasons for Dr. Gunter’s planned move next year back to Canada after practicing gynecology for 3 decades in the United States.

I referred to a recent GT I wrote about the WHI and the potential favorable impact of MHT on the immune system, as suggested by new data on organ clocks. That finding, which has been replicated, may be linked to healthy aging, extending healthspan.

****************************

Thanks to the >190,000 Ground Truths subscribers from every US state and 210 countries. Your subscription to these free essays and podcasts makes my work in putting them together worthwhile.

If you found this interesting PLEASE share it!

Paid subscriptions are voluntary and all proceeds from them go to support Scripps Research. They do allow for posting comments and questions, which I do my best to respond to. Please don’t hesitate to post comments and give me feedback. Let me know topics that you would like to see covered.

Many thanks to those who have contributed—they have greatly helped fund our summer internship programs for the past two years. It enabled us to accept and support 47 summer interns in 2025! We aim to accept even more of the several thousand who will apply for summer 2026.Thank you Debbie Weil, Cynthia Brumfield, Sara Garcia, Harshi Peiris, Ph.D., Liane Moccia, and over 1,000 others for tuning into my live video with Dr. Jen Gunter! Join me for my next live video in the app.