I think there was a moment in which the left could have seized on that as a broader critique of the way capitalism plays out in brazila. The right recognized the appeal and the power of these critiques as an anti political argument, so it's all bad. I would also add, just on top of that, something that's obvious to any left us, which is the reactionary impulses of the middle class  in going oto the sixties and beyond. So having like rakinli there, ou know, running the economic system of the country was a bad call, like from the beginning.