Is It Possible That Heh'd Been Abducted by a UFO?

Nichols speculates that after passing out, calvin woke up and charley told him that the two of them had been abducted. That could explain charley's belief that heh'd been abducted. But what about calvin? It would be really unlikely to have two people both doze off, have sleep paralysis and dream the same abduction scenario. So i don't think that nichols's non hoax theory is particularly promising.