
Alva Noe, “Varieties of Presence” (Harvard UP, 2012)
New Books in Philosophy
00:00
The Liades of Presence
I can't even think of a good one. I would say that, you know, finding out that Jonah didn't exist would be radically different in significance than saying Barack Obama doesn't exist. And we should allow for that possibility. But the really hard case for what you're talking about is dreaming. In dreaming, it seems that you actually have full-blown conscious states that depend not on the world around you, but just on what's going on in your heart. If you can have that, why couldn't, why couldn’t you have the whole shebang? Yeah. It's very difficult for me to state this super clearly, because the idea is so complicated, I
Transcript
Play full episode