How to Create a Character That Looks Completely Normal

Skinning and tanning probably isn't an interesting class to play. But herding cattle would be like Tetris because you're fitting all the different shaped cows. Do you think it would be possible to create a character that looks completely normal? We've already come up with shitty ideas for superheroes. What are you called? Man-Man. You just look like a normal bloke. Your superhero power is that you're a man, but really you're a lady. The team peed.