Is There a Beginning in the Universe?

One of the ways that we can rule out a theory is if there is some sort of logical inconsistency. I don't see ats being any problem for naturalism, given my view about modality. It seems to me that there's no inconsistency in the views that i've got. And as josh was just pointing out, if you take the hard problem of consciousness seriously, you're going to think that my views about the mental ar ously mistaken. But, you know, that's just something that we disagree about.