The Problem With Speculative Science

3min Snip

00:00

Play full episode

Summary

Transcript

Episode notes

I see these as features of the discourse where maybe you could say that it also comes from an overly centralized approach to the funding. I feel like quantum computing is a field where we haven't seen a working quantum computer doing things that are very useful for humanity yet. And so even though it's uncertain if we'll be able to do it, it has such strong theoretical foundations or something like cryptocurrency where there's kind of an algorithm that you can get. So in more theoretical fields or more theoretically driven fields I think maybe progress can be faster or more robust. But I don't have the solution.

Read the full transcript here.

What are focused research organizations? Which kinds of research projects lend themselves to the FRO model? Researchers in academia frequently complain about the incentive structures around funding and publishing; so how do FROs change those dynamics? Why must FROs be time-limited, especially if they're successful? Who's in charge in an FRO? How does "field-building" help to improve science? What effects might large language models have on science?

Adam Marblestone is the CEO of Convergent Research. He's been launching Focused Research Organizations (FROs) such as E11 bio and Cultivarium. He also serves on the boards of several non-profits pursuing new methods of funding and organizing scientific research including Norn Group and New Science. Previously, he was a Schmidt Futures Innovation Fellow, a consultant for the Astera Institute, a Fellow with the Federation of American Scientists (FAS), a research scientist at Google DeepMind, Chief Strategy Officer of the brain-computer interface company Kernel, a research scientist at MIT, a PhD student in biophysics with George Church and colleagues at Harvard, and a theoretical physics student at Yale. He also previously helped to start companies like BioBright and advised foundations such as the Open Philanthropy Project. His work has been recognized with a Technology Review 35 Innovators Under 35 Award (2018), a Fannie and John Hertz Foundation Fellowship (2010), and a Goldwater Scholarship (2008). Learn more about him at adammarblestone.org.

Staff