How Do You Give Critique When You're Asked?

i defer to their judgment and their decision making on anything that is a matter of taste or, you know, seems good to me. Almost never do i question things like plotter err characterization unless it is a real standout of an issue. Through new authors, i call out common mistakes such as using the same adjective six times in this paragraph and three times in this sentence. It's completely useless statement when you're getting a critique. But there something stands out as being well done, i'll call it out, and i'll say why i think it's well done. If something its mechanically broken, i'll let them know. So i've stopped doing this. Entirely. Exper