Navigating Domain Health for Effective Email Deliverability

#256 Email Deliverability | In this episode, Dan is joined by Sarah McNamara, Revenue Operations & GTM Strategy Lead at Vector, and Alex Fine, co-founder of Understory, an agency helping B2B SaaS companies scale with outbound, paid, and email. Both Sarah and Alex are experts in email strategy, specifically the behind-the-scenes mechanics that make or break your deliverability.

They break down what B2B marketers often overlook when it comes to getting emails opened, read, and replied to, and share practical tactics to improve performance across newsletters, outbound, and lifecycle campaigns.

Dan, Sarah, and Alex cover:

• Why email deliverability issues are more common than you think and how to spot them early
• The metrics that actually matter (hint: opens and clicks aren’t on the list)
• How to protect your domain reputation and warm up inboxes the right way

If email is part of your GTM motion, this episode will help you reach more inboxes and stop your messages from disappearing into the void.

Timestamps

• (00:00) - – Intro
• (03:44) - – Meet Sarah and Alex
• (05:49) - – Why email deliverability matters more than subject lines
• (08:04) - – How to tell if you have a deliverability problem
• (10:19) - – The most useful (and overlooked) deliverability metrics
• (12:39) - – Why replies matter more than opens or clicks
• (15:04) - – Tools Alex and Sarah use to monitor deliverability
• (17:19) - – Should you buy a dedicated IP?
• (19:14) - – How to evaluate platforms for deliverability
• (21:34) - – Getting sales to care about data hygiene
• (24:04) - – Deliverability tips for small senders and solopreneurs
• (29:05) - – Subdomains vs. secondary domains
• (31:55) - – How many inboxes per domain is too many?
• (34:00) - – Best practices for cold outreach
• (36:50) - – How security bots skew your open and click data
• (39:50) - – What counts as “spam” (and how filters decide)
• (43:05) - – How to re-engage cold or inactive lists
• (45:50) - – What to A/B test in subject lines (and when it’s pointless)
• (49:00) - – How to build a healthy, opt-in list from scratch
• (51:50) - – When to stop emailing cold leads
• (54:05) - – Welcome sequence tips for engaged subscribers
• (57:00) - – How to warm up a new domain
• (01:00:20) - – Final takeaways and advice

Send guest pitches and ideas to hi@exitfive.com
Join the Exit Five Newsletter here: https://www.exitfive.com/newsletter
Check out the Exit Five job board: https://jobs.exitfive.com/
Become an Exit Five member: https://community.exitfive.com/checkout/exit-five-membership

***

Today’s episode is brought to you by Zuddl.

We’re halfway through 2025, and one thing’s clear: events continue to be one of the highest performing marketing channels. Niche meetups, conferences, curated dinners, networking - you name it. Everyone’s leaning in.

Events are a core part of our playbook this year at Exit Five. So far, we’ve hosted two virtual sessions each month, one large virtual event, one in-person meetup, and we’re deep in the weeds planning our Drive conference coming back to Vermont this September.

Zuddl helps us run a smarter event strategy - from driving registrations, managing invites, automating comms, reminders, analytics, tracking. Their Salesforce integration also makes it simple to report on pipeline and revenue from events without pulling in ops.

On top of that, the differentiator with Zuddl is how their team is insanely good at supporting us. They always go above and beyond for us - and that’s how we’ve been able to keep the momentum going with 12+ events already this year, with plenty more to come.

If events are part of your marketing strategy, you need to look at Zuddl to see how companies like Zillow, CrowdStrike, and Iterable are using the top event platform for Business events in 2025. 

Head over to zuddl.com/exitfive to learn more.