Intro

You can say anything in America—except the wrong thing about Israel.

In the past six months, we've watched prominent intellectuals, professors, journalists, and even former allies of the conservative movement lose jobs or platforms simply for questioning whether the United States' relationship with Israel is just, wise, or even Christian. Not because they denied Israel's right to exist, not because they justified Hamas—but because they dared to ask whether endless, unquestioned allegiance to a foreign nation is compatible with America First.

Meanwhile, public opinion is shifting. Support for Israel is at a generational low, especially among younger Americans. Donald Trump—arguably the most pro-Israel president in history—has reportedly cut Netanyahu out of the negotiation process. Something's changing. But what exactly?

Is it just fatigue—another weary chapter in a long Middle East drama we no longer want to fund? Or is it a deeper theological reformation—a rejection of the Scofield system that bound American patriotism to Israeli foreign policy and bound the church to a dispensational timeline at odds with historic Christianity?

But here’s the tension: is this discussion already burning people out? Is the “Israel question” fracturing coalitions that were making real headway elsewhere? Brett Weinstein says it shattered the medical freedom movement. Tucker Carlson notes it’s splintering MAGA. Are we on the verge of letting an ancient and complex foreign conflict derail critical domestic work—on the family, on the economy, on liberty?

This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors, Armored Republic and Reece Fund, as well as our Patreon members and donors. You can join our Patreon at patreon.com/rightresponseministries or donate at rightresponseministries.com/donate.

So where do we go from here? What does righteous, strategic engagement look like now? What should we say—and when should we be silent? And is it possible to call for clarity without fueling division? Let’s talk about it.

MINISTRY SPONSORS:

• Reece Fund. Christian Capital. Boldly Deployed
  https://www.reecefund.com/



• Private Family Banking
  How to Connect with Private Family Banking:
  1. FREE 20-MINUTE COURSE HERE: View Course
  2. Send an email inquiry to chuck@privatefamilybanking.com
  3. Receive a FREE e-book entitled "How to Build Multi-Generational Wealth Outside of Wall Street and Avoid the Coming Banking Meltdown": protectyourmoneynow.net
  4. Set up a FREE Private Family Banking Discovery call: Schedule Here
  5. Multi-Generational Wealth Planning Guide Book for only $4.99: Seven Generations Legacy



• Western Front Books. Publishing for men on the right. Not churchy. Christian.
  https://www.WesternFrontBooks.com/



• Mid State Accounting
  Does your small business need help with bookkeeping, tax returns, and fractional CFO services? Call Kailee Smith at 573‑889‑7278 for a free, no‑obligation consultation. Mention the Right Response podcast and get 10% off your first three months.



• Kingsmen Caps
  Carry the Crown with Kingsmen Caps — premium headwear made for those who honor Christ as King. Create your custom crown or shop our latest releases at https://kingsmencaps.com.



• Squirrelly Joes Coffee – Caffeinating The Modern Reformation
  Get a free bag of coffee (just pay shipping): https://squirrellyjoes.com/rightresponse