Star Trek - Is Captain Janeway the Better Star Trek Captain?

"I have never been much of a Star Trek guy at all. I don't have anything against it, but I've just never spent any time with it," he says. "The new Kirk is very interesting in a way that the old Kirk I just found ridiculous." In Voyager there was a big disagreement between the writers about what Captain Janeway's character should be and they split into two groups which were basically Captain Mom versus the Iron Lady. The actress Kate Mulgrew decided to simply play the character as though she has shell shock.