The Power of Advertising: Influencing Consumer Choices

In this episode of The Brainy Business podcast, host Melina Palmer dives into the fascinating world of behavioral economics and its application in Peloton's marketing success. As a marketing expert, Melina understands the importance of effective messaging and branding strategies, and she shares her insights on how Peloton has leveraged behavioral economics concepts to create a strong connection with their target audience. 

She explores the power of storytelling, community-building, and framing offers in a way that resonates with customers. Melina also discusses the impact of social proof, herding, and anchoring in Peloton's advertising and business strategies. If you're a marketer or business owner looking to enhance your branding and advertising strategies, this episode is a must-listen. Melina's expertise and analysis of Peloton's success will inspire you to apply behavioral economics principles in your own marketing efforts and build a loyal customer base.

In this episode:

• Enhance your branding and advertising strategies by applying behavioral economics concepts for a Peloton-like success.
• Discover the importance of aligning your messaging with your target audiences for more effective advertising.
• Uncover the power of storytelling and community-building to create a strong brand identity and engage customers.
• Learn how to leverage social proof and herding to enhance motivation and engagement within your community.
• Understand the impact of ad controversy and mixed messaging, and how to avoid it in your own advertising campaigns.

Show Notes:

00:00:00 - Introduction, Melina Palmer introduces the podcast episode and explains the purpose of the Behavioral Economics Analysis series. She emphasizes the importance of understanding how companies apply behavioral economics concepts and provides ideas for implementing them in one's own business. 00:03:49 - Background on Peloton, Melina provides an overview of Peloton, a fitness company that sells workout equipment and offers streaming classes. She shares statistics on the company's membership, workout completion, and revenue. She also mentions the controversy surrounding a Peloton holiday ad and the mixed messaging in the company's marketing. 00:07:21 - Mixed Messaging in Peloton's Marketing, Melina discusses the issue of mixed messaging in Peloton's marketing. She explains that while the company aims to be inclusive, their ads primarily target wealthy individuals. This creates a disconnect with their message of building a community accessible to everyone. She suggests that Peloton should align their marketing with their target audience more clearly. 00:09:52 - Inclusivity vs. High-Income Targeting, Melina discusses the two paths Peloton could take in their marketing strategy: inclusivity or targeting high-income individuals. She emphasizes the importance of clarity and consistency in messaging and highlights the need for proper context in ads to avoid negative interpretations. 00:11:10 - Importance of Providing Context in Ads, Melina stresses the importance of providing context in ads, especially when it comes to sensitive topics like health and fitness. Without proper context, viewers may fill in the gaps. 00:15:07 - Utilizing Stories and Community in Advertising, Peloton has a wealth of stories and people that can be used in advertising to inspire others and promote the brand. They should engage their community and ask for stories to feature. 00:17:38 - Potential Benefits of Controversial Advertising, While Peloton received backlash for their controversial ad, it brought awareness to the brand and the problem they solve. Seeing the ad everywhere can increase focus on the company and prompt people to learn more. 00:19:55 - Peloton's Pricing Strategy, Peloton offers an expensive product, but they make it easier for customers to try with a 30-day trial and financing options. The 94% stay rate at the twelve month mark shows that once people have the equipment, they are likely to continue using it. 00:21:28 - Access to Content and Reciprocity, Peloton's monthly membership fee gives access to high-quality content, creating a sense of reciprocity. They bundle offers without discounting, providing additional benefits for customers who buy the bike or treadmill. 00:26:22 - Structuring Choices for Customer Satisfaction, Peloton structures their choices by allowing users to easily search and filter for classes based on their preferences. They have ten main categories to start with and provide recommended rides based on users' preferences. 00:31:08 - Herding and Social Proof on Peloton, Peloton's use of herding and social proof enhances the community experience, with features like showing how many people have taken a class before, following other users, and rating classes. This creates a sense of community without the awkwardness. 00:32:29 - Framing and Tracking Progress, Peloton's instructors guide users on what numbers to focus on during workouts, emphasizing resistance and cadence. By framing what matters and providing robust stats, Peloton makes it easy to track progress and strive for improvement. 00:35:45 - Incorporating Social Proof, Peloton creates a sense of community by incorporating social proof, such as calling out names and profiles of people hitting milestones during live workouts. Badges, achievements, and virtual high fives further enhance the feeling of being part of a larger community. 00:40:06 - The Impact of "I See You", Peloton's instructors use the phrase "I see you" when giving shout outs, creating a personal and inclusive atmosphere. This subtle phrasing adds to the social proof and makes users feel like part of a big family. Anchoring and commitments also help form good habits and keep users motivated. 00:46:20 - Key Takeaways from Peloton's Advertising Strategy, Key takeaways from Peloton's advertising strategy include knowing your target market, using real stories from your community, and making complex offerings easy for users. Context and storytelling are important, as well as anchoring and social proof to create a sense of community and connection. 00:47:46 - Importance of User Experience and Choice Structure, The user experience is crucial, especially when it comes to structuring choices. Making it easy for users to navigate and personalize their experience is key, particularly for those trying to change habits. Defaults and remembered settings can help facilitate this process. 00:48:28 - Anchoring and Social Proof for Building a Community, Anchoring with big numbers helps show what's possible and move people beyond their initial expectations. Social proof is essential for creating a sense of community, whether it's through personalized shoutouts or highlighting the presence of a larger community. 00:49:42 - Pricing Strategies and Knowing Your Audience, Pricing doesn't always have to be about discounts. Understanding your audience's mindset and what matters to them can help in setting prices. Not every business is for every person, and it's okay if some people don't resonate with your pricing. 00:51:52 - Personalized Virtual Experiences and the Potential for Business Growth, Peloton's ability to create a personalized virtual experience highlights the potential for businesses to offer virtual services with a subscription or membership model. 

00:53:24 -  Conclusion, Melina's top insights from the conversation. What stuck with you while listening to the episode? What are you going to try? Come share it with Melina on social media -- you'll find her as @thebrainybiz everywhere and as Melina Palmer on LinkedIn.

Thanks for listening. Don’t forget to subscribe on Apple Podcasts or Android. If you like what you heard, please leave a review on iTunes and share what you liked about the show. 

I hope you love everything recommended via The Brainy Business! Everything was independently reviewed and selected by me, Melina Palmer. So you know, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. That means if you decide to shop from the links on this page (via Amazon or others), The Brainy Business may collect a share of sales or other compensation.

Let’s connect:

• Melina@TheBrainyBusiness.com
• The Brainy Business® on Facebook
• The Brainy Business on Twitter
• The Brainy Business on Instagram
• The Brainy Business on LinkedIn
• Melina on LinkedIn
• The Brainy Business on Youtube

Learn and Support The Brainy Business:

Check out and get your copies of Melina’s Books. 

Get the Books Mentioned on (or related to) this Episode:

• Good Habits, Bad Habits, by Wendy Wood
• Purpose, by Gina Bianchini
• What Your Customer Wants and Can’t Tell You, by Melina Palmer
• Atomic Habits, by James Clear
• Engaged, by Amy Bucher

Top Recommended Next Episode: The Science of Subscriptions and Membership Models (ep 105)

Already Heard That One? Try These: 

• Costco: A Behavioral Economics Analysis (ep 47)
• Disney: A Behavioral Economics Analysis (ep 292)
• Starbucks: A Behavioral Economics Analysis (ep 278)
• Apple Card: A Behavioral Economics Analysis (ep 42)
• Availability Bias (ep 310)
• Framing (ep 296)
• How to Stack and Bundle Products and Services To Sell More (ep 84)
• How to Raise Your Prices (ep 77)
• Reciprocity (ep 238)
• Structuring Complex Choices: The “S” in NUDGES (ep 41)
• Herding (ep 264)
• Anchoring & Adjustment (ep 11)
• Habits (ep 256)
• How to Get (and Stay) Motivated (ep 67)
• The Network Effect (ep 262)
• Creating a Habit of Curiosity with Pique (ep 119)
• Precommitment (ep 120)
• Get Your DOSE Of Brain Chemicals (ep 123)
• Good Habits, Bad Habits with Wendy Wood (ep 127)
• Find Your Purpose, with Gina Bianchini (ep 263)
• Surprise & Delight (ep 276)

Other Important Links: 

• Brainy Bites - Melina’s LinkedIn Newsletter
• The real lesson your credit union should learn from Peloton’s ad flop (it’s not what you think)
• The Gift That Gives Back | Peloton Bike Commercial
• Peloton Investor Relations
• Peloton’s nightmare before Christmas: $1.5 billion vanished from its market value in 3 days amid holiday ad backlash