Cybernetics and Closed-Loop Learning

What if everything we think we know about AI understanding is wrong? Is compression the key to intelligence? Or is there something more—a leap from memorization to true abstraction?

In this fascinating conversation, we sit down with **Professor Yi Ma**—world-renowned expert in deep learning, IEEE/ACM Fellow, and author of the groundbreaking new book *Learning Deep Representations of Data Distributions*. Professor Ma challenges our assumptions about what large language models actually do, reveals why 3D reconstruction isn't the same as understanding, and presents a unified mathematical theory of intelligence built on just two principles: **parsimony** and **self-consistency**.

**SPONSOR MESSAGES START**

—

Prolific - Quality data. From real people. For faster breakthroughs.

https://www.prolific.com/?utm_source=mlst

—

cyber•Fund https://cyber.fund/?utm_source=mlst is a founder-led investment firm accelerating the cybernetic economy

Hiring a SF VC Principal: https://talent.cyber.fund/companies/cyber-fund-2/jobs/57674170-ai-investment-principal#content?utm_source=mlst

Submit investment deck: https://cyber.fund/contact?utm_source=mlst

—

**END**

Key Insights:

**LLMs Don't Understand—They Memorize**

Language models process text (*already* compressed human knowledge) using the same mechanism we use to learn from raw data.

**The Illusion of 3D Vision**

Sora and NeRFs etc that can reconstruct 3D scenes still fail miserably at basic spatial reasoning

**"All Roads Lead to Rome"**

Why adding noise is *necessary* for discovering structure.

**Why Gradient Descent Actually Works**

Natural optimization landscapes are surprisingly smooth—a "blessing of dimensionality"

**Transformers from First Principles**

Transformer architectures can be mathematically derived from compression principles

—

INTERACTIVE AI TRANSCRIPT PLAYER w/REFS (ReScript):

https://app.rescript.info/public/share/Z-dMPiUhXaeMEcdeU6Bz84GOVsvdcfxU_8Ptu6CTKMQ

About Professor Yi Ma

Yi Ma is the inaugural director of the School of Computing and Data Science at Hong Kong University and a visiting professor at UC Berkeley.

https://people.eecs.berkeley.edu/~yima/

https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=XqLiBQMAAAAJ&hl=en

https://x.com/YiMaTweets

**Slides from this conversation:**

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/sbhbyievw7idup8j06mlr/slides.pdf?rlkey=7ptovemezo8bj8tkhfi393fh9&dl=0

**Related Talks by Professor Ma:**

- Pursuing the Nature of Intelligence (ICLR): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LT-F0xSNSjo

- Earlier talk at Berkeley: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TihaCUjyRLM

TIMESTAMPS:

00:00:00 Introduction

00:02:08 The First Principles Book & Research Vision

00:05:21 Two Pillars: Parsimony & Consistency

00:09:50 Evolution vs. Learning: The Compression Mechanism

00:14:36 LLMs: Memorization Masquerading as Understanding

00:19:55 The Leap to Abstraction: Empirical vs. Scientific

00:27:30 Platonism, Deduction & The ARC Challenge

00:35:57 Specialization & The Cybernetic Legacy

00:41:23 Deriving Maximum Rate Reduction

00:48:21 The Illusion of 3D Understanding: Sora & NeRF

00:54:26 All Roads Lead to Rome: The Role of Noise

00:59:56 All Roads Lead to Rome: The Role of Noise

01:00:14 Benign Non-Convexity: Why Optimization Works

01:06:35 Double Descent & The Myth of Overfitting

01:14:26 Self-Consistency: Closed-Loop Learning

01:21:03 Deriving Transformers from First Principles

01:30:11 Verification & The Kevin Murphy Question

01:34:11 CRATE vs. ViT: White-Box AI & Conclusion

REFERENCES:

Book:

[00:03:04] Learning Deep Representations of Data Distributions

https://ma-lab-berkeley.github.io/deep-representation-learning-book/

[00:18:38] A Brief History of Intelligence

https://www.amazon.co.uk/BRIEF-HISTORY-INTELLIGEN-HB-Evolution/dp/0008560099

[00:38:14] Cybernetics

https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262730099/cybernetics/

Book (Yi Ma):

[00:03:14] 3-D Vision book

https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-0-387-21779-6

<TRUNC> refs on ReScript link/YT