The Case of Bill Maguire

Melanie Maguire had given away most of her deceased husband's things, including his clothing, weight set, and dumbbells. De-exercise equipment was tracked down, but it did not match the 5.5-pound weight from the suitcase that contained Bill's torso. Detectives were informed by the storage facility manager that Melanie owned a second smaller locker that she had failed to inform them about. When asked if they could search this second locker, Melanie appeared surprised but consented. Inside, detectives found Bill's wallet, which contained his social security and health insurance cards, a few business cards, and pictures of his family.