
#574 – DIALOGUE: Does the Kalam argument work? (with Alex Malpass)
The Counsel of Trent
00:00
Is God's Hotel Impossible?
Hilbert's hotel is impossible. Therefore, god can't destroy hotel rooms once a day for the rest of the endless future. He lacks that capacity because there couldn't be hilbert’s hotel in the present. For him to be able to keep destroying hotel rooms once per day forever, there'd have to be hilberts hotel in the past. But then i think that's exactly the analysis you should take to the past case too. I mean, an it's just not possible for god to have created a hotel room every day in thePast. Its exactly the same reason. Ye. And i say, i would have to give it some more thought.
Transcript
Play full episode