Exploring the perplexing life of Patrick Coleman, the chapter investigates his unusual behaviors, record-setting achievements possibly aided by Indigenous Guides, and the mysterious shooting incident reflecting paranoia. Delving into the historical context of arsenic and its dual usage, the hosts reflect on the challenges of detecting arsenic poisoning amidst the backdrop of unregulated patent medicines and mysterious individuals. The narrative intertwines the enigmatic stories of Mary Ann Hall and her absent husband with the complexities of 19th-century military life, drawing striking parallels to contemporary experiences of separation and government payouts.