No that's one of those books that like if you any no no reread is a deepening it is a like how did it happen yeah right. Aside from david you get enough about three or four of the other kids to to the librarians and then i will just like kind of make some extra connections um so what other characters haven't we talked about how do they relate to carolin? I think in like pretty insane honestly but it's because she is coping with like having to be killed by father over and over and over againUm michael i think is the name of the guy who communicates with animals and he spends so much time communicating with animals that it is hard for him to