Is There a Rubric for Data Analysis?

i feel like it's easy to come up with rubric that would be satisfied by any good data analysis, right? But the question is, if i told you this data analysis scored high on the rubric, like, whould you think it was good? Right? That's the real question. Like, what is the kind of posterior predictive value of the rubric itself? Yes. And i don't think i've ever created a rubric that had a high P-value. I mean, no, probably not, right? Ye, ye, yes. What i like about the rubric idea is that when i think of a rubric, i don't thinking of checking