
OA553: The Supreme Court Commission Failed. Gabe Roth Joins Us to Discuss Why
Opening Arguments
00:00
Do You Think the Division of Duties Could Work Retroactively?
Argument number one: Congress has broad constitutional authority to constitute inferior courts, not to mess around with the supreme court. Argument number two: The division of duties argument is an implementation based argument that would suffer from the same defects as article number one. Arguments three and four are textual support; they don't work retroactively.
Transcript
Play full episode