Why the SEC’s Case Against Coinbase Is So Significant for Crypto - Ep. 597
Unchained
Judicial Scrutiny of SEC's Regulatory Reach in Crypto
This chapter examines the implications of the SEC's ongoing case against a major crypto exchange, highlighting the judge's doubts about the SEC's position. It explores the potential precedents for future crypto regulations and the careful balance the judge must strike in his ruling.
On Wednesday, a federal court in New York heard oral arguments in Coinbase’s motion to dismiss the SEC’s case against it for, among other things, allegedly acting as an unregulated securities exchange. Notably, Judge Katherine Polk Failla pressed the SEC to explain how it has jurisdiction over Coinbase in the case by defining what it considers a security.
Sam Enzer, a partner at Cahill Gorden & Reindel who represents Coinbase but not in this matter, joined Unchained to discuss why this case is so significant for the crypto industry, how he believes the government contradicted itself on the crucial definition of what constitutes a security, why he thinks the judge will not dismiss the case at this early stage, how the Ripple and Terraform Labs cases could be used by each side, and why he thinks Judge Failla is such a perfect choice to rule in this case.
Show highlights:
- Why SEC v Coinbase holds important implications for the U.S. crypto ecosystem
- What the SEC alleges against Coinbase, focusing on its trading platform, wallet, and staking services
- How Coinbase forcefully counters the SEC's claims as it strives to get the case dismissed
- What the “major questions doctrine” entails and its critical role in this dispute
- Why Sam perceives the judge as “extremely skeptical” of the SEC's stance
- Whether inconsistencies surfaced in the SEC lawyers' arguments
- What “strict liability” means and its frequent mention in this legal battle
- What takeaways from the Ripple and Terraform Labs cases offer about secondary market sales
- Why Sam believes Judge Katherine Polk Failla is exceptionally well-suited for this case
- Whether Judge Failla might reject the motion to dismiss, and when
Thank you to our sponsors!
Guest
- Sam Enzer, partner at Cahill Gordon & Reindel
- Previous appearances on Unchained:
- Why SBF's Testimony So Far Has Likely Already Doomed Him
- Another Bad Week for Sam Bankman-Fried in His Criminal Trial
- Why These Lawyers Say It's Over for SBF-But His Only Hail Mary Is to Testify
- SBF Trial: How Sam Bankman-Fried’s Lawyers Might Try and Win His Case
- SBF’s Lawyers Could Be Annoying the Judge How Might That Impact the Trial?
Links
- Previous coverage of Unchained on the Coinbase case and the topic of securities:
- SEC Sues Binance, Coinbase: ‘This Is Not the End of Crypto in the United States’
- These 2 Crypto Trading Platforms Agree With SEC Chair Gary Gensler
- Coinbase’s Legal Action Against the SEC: How It Will Likely Unfold
- ‘Is ETH a Security?’ Why Gary Gensler Couldn’t Give Congress a Straight Answer
- Gary Gensler vs. Crypto: What Will the SEC Attack Next?
- Rep. Emmer on Why He Believes Gary Gensler Is a ‘Bad-Faith Regulator’
Coinbase vs. SEC
- Unchained:
- Federal Judge Presses SEC Over Jurisdiction in Case Against Coinbase
- SEC Sues Coinbase for Breaking Securities Laws
- SEC Files Motion to Freeze Binance’s Assets, Asks for ‘Sworn Accounting’
- SEC Files 13 Charges Against Binance Including the Mishandling of Funds, Sale of Unregistered Securities
- SEC Calls Solana, Polygon, Algorand and Other Tokens Securities but Misses Ether in Binance Lawsuit
- Cointelegraph: Senator Lummis files amicus brief supporting Coinbase’s dismissal motion against SEC.
Other cases
Kraken
XRP
Terraform Labs
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
The AI-powered Podcast Player
