How Can She Gain New Information From Red?

Fid, a milliong out of the analogy i'm making my bookisi like come it is clearly different to say that she knows what nurons would fire if she saw red, and to have those nurons fire. You can not ot not epoinnoformation, if you want, but either you're begging the question about some phenomena,. logical phenomenal experience, being non physical, and that's what she's gaining information about. Or she's just having something different happen in her head that ever happened. And i think that's perfectly reasonable.