The Aruban Police Force 'Brought Out Their Big Guns', Saying, "Mom, Help Me"

Beth Twitty returned to the United States after four months in a ruba searching for her daughter. Accusations that the Aruban police force was purposely thwarting the investigation as part of some kind of cover-up ran rife in the US. In early October, Beth received a voicemail on her phone from a private number. The message contained a female voice saying, Mom, help me. FBI analyzed the voicemail against genuine recordings of Natalie's voice and ultimately ruled it out as a hoax.