Ep. 70 The Aloneness Argument Against Classical Theism with Joe Schmid
The Reluctant Theologian Podcast
00:00
The Proposed Counterexample to Our Understanding of Extrinsicality
The proposed counter example to our understanding of extrinsicality is the property of being alone. So, jol, how do we respond to an objection like this? Yes, so this is a good objection because it makes the dialectic clearer and more precise, really. We actually give three replies to this in the paper,. And i'll just take us, at least for now, through the first two replies that we give. Here's the rst reply. These proposed counter examples are what david lewis calls negative extrinsic properties. They report some absince or lack or failure of the subject. Other proposed counter examples include not being six meters away from any rhodod
Transcript
Play full episode
