How Performance Culture Affects Church Practice

Travis Michael Fleming and Mark Sayers do a cultural apologetic deep dive into one of the structures influencing church today and how we have become a platform society. They discuss Sayers' book, "Platforms to Pillars," which examines the evolving nature of leadership in the modern world. They start off their conversation with an eye-opening revelation from a United Nations report indicating that 60% of people globally feel dissatisfied with their lives, presenting a paradox as other indicators show progress in living standards. This phenomenon introduces the concept of the 'platform pain point,' where the pursuit of visibility through digital platforms often leads to isolation rather than community.

Sayers articulates how modern society has shifted from valuing institutional integrity to prioritizing individual platforms, which can lead to rapid rises and falls among leaders. He expresses concern over the performative nature of contemporary leadership, where the cultivation of a public persona can overshadow genuine character and authenticity. The conversation further explores the implications of this shift for ministry leaders, who must navigate a landscape that increasingly values performance metrics over relational depth. Sayers advocates for a return to the notion of 'pillars'—individuals who embody wisdom, stability, and community support.

Throughout the episode, Sayers encourages listeners to reevaluate their roles in fostering authentic connections within their communities. He posits that true leadership requires a commitment to cultivating spiritual authority through personal struggles and faithfulness, rather than succumbing to the pressures of a performance-driven culture. This insightful dialogue not only critiques the current cultural landscape but also provides a transformative vision for leaders seeking to make a meaningful impact in an age characterized by disconnection and superficiality.

Takeaways:

• The UN report indicates a significant global dissatisfaction where 60% of people feel pessimistic about the future despite historical improvements in living standards.
• The concept of platforms in leadership has evolved, where individuals now prioritize building a platform over serving institutions, leading to a crisis in leadership legitimacy.
• Cultural apologetics, as articulated by Travis, plays a crucial role in establishing the Christian voice within contemporary culture amidst rising secularism.
• The phenomenon of platform pain points highlights the paradox of increased connectivity through social media, yet a growing sense of individual disconnection and dissatisfaction.
• The shift from platforms to pillars emphasizes the need for collective wisdom and community support over individualistic pursuits in modern ministry contexts.
• As society trends towards individualism, the church must navigate the challenges of maintaining genuine community and spiritual authority in a performance-driven culture.

Sign up for our next Blueprint cohort.

Read the review of Platforms to Pillars.

Keep up with updates from Apollos Watered: The Center for Discipleship & Cultural Apologetics.

Get Travis's book Blueprint: Kingdom Living in the Modern World.

Join Travis's Substack, Deep Roots Society

Help support the ministry of Apollos Watered and transform your world today!