The Mystery of Renaldo Pays

Matthew Alritt was last seen playing in the backyard of his home in Clara Mel City, Pennsylvania on January 16th 1993. His family held a memorial service for him almost exactly 19 years after he went missing. No evidence has been found to prove that Renaldo Pays killed and strangled their son. But those who are left behind can't help but wonder what would possess such a kindly old man to kill an innocent young boy.