The Axeman Killing Spree

John D'Antonio, an Italian immigrant, came forward with a theory. He believes the man who committed the Axeman murders is the same one who killed several victims back in 1911. So he believed this wasn't the Axeman's first killing spree. Which would make sense, with a strange clue found near the Magio house on the night of the first Axeman killings in 1918. You mean the chicken scratch and chalk on the sidewalk that read? The smagio will sit up tonight. Looks like Mrs. Tony. That could link the murders of Joseph and Catherine Magio to the killing of Tony Chiambrough, also by an axe back in 2011. But if