With selfhood itself at stake, it's no wonder otherwise rational and tolerant people tip toe around the topic. In a sexually reproducing mammalian species like ours, females and males should be able to be defined as such. Sex chromosomes aren't always XX and XY, and birds for example, males have a pair of identical sex chromosomes, Z, Z, and females have two different ones, Z, W. Many species don't even rely on chromosomes to make males and females; in turtles and crocodiles, it's the temperature of the eggs that determines the sex of the hatchlings.
In this special episode of the Michael Shermer Show Dr. Shermer comments on current events surrounding trans matters and reads his in-depth essay on the subject, originally published as one of his regularly Skeptic columns on Substack.