Clarence Elkins and Melinda Elkins

Clarence Elkins was convicted of murdering his mother-in-law Judy Johnson in 1999. The prosecution used the testimony of six-year-old Brooke Sutton to identify Clarence as the attacker. A DNA test came back negative and a retrial was refused by the judge who had no prior experience with murder trials. After years of investigation, Melinda found evidence that proved her husband's innocence.