
Is Psychoanalysis Still Relevant in Modern Psychiatry?
Psychofarm Podcast
How do internalized representations shape behavior?
Gregory explains internal templates of self and others, reenactment of early schemas, and the clinical effects of nonintegrated representations.
Is psychoanalysis still relevant in modern psychiatry and medication management? We unpack psychodynamic therapy, DSM-5 personality disorders, object relations, ego psychology, splitting, projective identification, attachment theory, and how solid psychiatric formulation improves outcomes in even medication management.
What we cover
* The opening question of whether psychoanalysis matters in an era of medication management, and why the terms psychoanalysis, psychoanalytic psychotherapy and psychodynamic therapy are used loosely, with the hosts disagreeing on whether they differ.
* A quick tour of the schools: Freud's drive theory, Anna Freud and ego psychology, object relations (Klein and Kernberg), Kohut's self psychology, relational approaches, and a brief word on Lacan, plus a debate on jargon versus plain language.
* Where psychoanalytic ideas sit in modern practice: the origin of talk therapy, the melancholic subtype of depression, CBT, and the idea of 'cargo cult' psychiatry when the DSM is taken at face value without its history.
* Personality organization on a neurotic, borderline and psychotic continuum, how this differs from psychosis as a biological syndrome, and the point that the DSM general personality criteria and alternative model in Section III are rarely read.
* Development and object relations: the unconscious, Erikson's stages, attachment theory, the paranoid-schizoid and depressive positions, the manic defense, splitting and projective identification.
* Id, ego and superego, language and naming as part of treatment, the loss of the old Axis I and Axis II split, and how psychological formulation helps even in medication management.
Clinical takeaways
* A psychological formulation can explain apparent treatment resistance. One host describes patients with ten or more medication trials where nobody had formulated how personality shaped the presentation.
* Read the general personality disorder criteria and the surrounding text, not only the checklists. Many patients are better described by traits and general personality dysfunction than by one named disorder.
* Expect splitting. A patient may make the clinician all good or all bad, and projective identification can pull clinicians into feeling what the patient expects from others. Recognizing it is the first step in managing it, and the hosts note that everyone splits under strain.
* Naming a condition can reorganize a patient's story and lower stress, but a label helps or harms depending on accuracy and fit. Patients often arrive with strong, culturally shaped ideas about what they have.
* Personality runs through every diagnosis. A diagnosis is a small slice of the person and meant to guide treatment, and personality does not come off like sunglasses when mood improves.
* In medication management, one host aims for a way of living that moves the patient toward what they want rather than permanent remission. The other host thinks that idea does not need psychoanalytic language.
Read the full transcript
The complete transcript of this episode is on psycho.farm: Is Psychoanalysis Still Relevant in Modern Psychiatry?.
Related episodes
* Psychodynamic Technique and Therapeutic Intervention: Containment
* What Psychiatrists Get Wrong About Personality Disorders
For education only. Not medical advice.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit psychofarm.substack.com


